Kelly Clarkson and John Legend faced backlash after critiquing Gyth Rigdon’s rendition of “God Bless the USA” on The Voice. Judges on the show usually avoid politics but are known for guiding singers to improve. Rigdon’s patriotic performance stirred controversy, with Clarkson and Legend criticized for questioning the song choice. Clarkson joked, “I feel like you can’t critique this song or you’re going to hell or something.”
Despite acknowledging Rigdon’s personal connection to the song, both judges gave honest assessments of his performance. Legend praised Rigdon’s energy, while Clarkson admitted it wasn’t her favorite. Their comments sparked criticism on Twitter, with viewers feeling they were too harsh.
The incident highlights the challenge judges face in balancing constructive criticism with respecting performers’ song choices. It also reminds us of the subjective nature of art and differing audience perspectives.
